This is a shopping guide, not a store. For the current season, start with the 2026 holiday gift guide. We list producers we could verify on November 11, 2026, describe them with facts from their official sites, and send you there so you can see current bottles, shipping rules, and prices. Wine, cider, and spirits shipments are limited by law; each producer’s site will tell you where they can ship.
Looking for a Keuka Lake visit or holiday calendar, not a mail-order gift? Living on Keuka is a related guide to life around the lake, including a start-here page and a 2026 Keuka and Finger Lakes holiday events list. For makers from across New York State, see the sibling site Shop New York State.
Browse by lake or by kind of gift
All of the buying guides are collected on the gift guides page.
2026 holiday gifts
Wine-country gifts
Local food gifts
Lake-life gifts
Art & local gifts
Keuka Lake
Seneca Lake
Cayuga & Canandaigua
Maple
Cheese
Crafts
A few places to start
Hammondsport, Keuka Lake
Dr. Konstantin Frank Winery
A pioneering Finger Lakes estate. In the late 1950s Dr. Frank planted vinifera grapes on Keuka Lake — a move the winery credits with helping change what New York wine could be. Shop and plan a tasting on the official site.
Visit the official site
Interlaken
Lively Run Dairy
A family creamery in Interlaken that has been making cheese in the Finger Lakes since 1982. Cheeses are made at the farm; milk comes from partner farms in the region and beyond. Cayuga Blue and other cheeses are sold from the official site.
Visit the official site
Canandaigua
Timber Trails Forest Farm
A family-owned 250-acre farm at 5585 County Road 33 that produces organic, wood-fired maple syrup. The official site has the sugar shop and farm information.
Visit the official site
Penn Yan
The Windmill Farm & Craft Market
A farm and craft market just south of Penn Yan on Route 14A, on 44 acres, with more than 175 indoor and outdoor shops. Confirm the current Saturday-season calendar on the official site.
Visit the official site
Local art gifts
For a gift that hangs on the wall instead of going in the pantry, Lakes & Tiers Gallery is a new online marketplace for original art and limited-edition prints from Finger Lakes and Southern Tier artists, browsable by lake or by the Southern Tier. Sales are opening soon; you can join the waitlist to hear when buying opens.
Are you a Finger Lakes or Southern Tier artist? The gallery is taking applications from founding artists — listing is free. See join as a founding artist.
Lakes & Tiers Gallery shares an owner with this guide. We do not earn a commission on gallery sales.
Picnic and tasting extras
The makers above sell the gifts themselves. If you also need a simple carrier or a board for a tasting at home, these Amazon searches are a practical add-on — not a substitute for a bottle or a wheel from the farm.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Amazon links on this page use the site tag and are disclosed on the disclosure page.
This is an independent guide, not a store and not a tourism-bureau website. We do not sell these products. See About, Contact, and Disclosure.